Black Phone 2: Grabber Returns From Hell

As reported by Bloody Disgusting, the genesis of this sequel actually came from a simple, yet potent, idea from Joe Hill himself. He apparently suggested to director Scott Derrickson and screenwriter Robert Cargill, "A phone rings, Finney answers, and it's The Grabber calling from hell." That single line seems to have sparked something, leading to a new adventure for Finney and his sister Gwen, who we saw survive the horrors of the first film.
The filmmakers are taking us in a new direction this time, setting the sequel at a winter camp in the Rocky Mountains. Director Derrickson mentioned how the stark, cold environment of a winter camp, which he experienced as a teen, became a compelling backdrop, offering a different kind of chill than the usual summer camp horror tropes. It’s a setting that sounds both beautiful and incredibly isolating, which, in a horror context, just amplifies the suspense.
What’s particularly intriguing is how The Grabber, originally a very real and terrifying presence, is returning in a supernatural capacity. One review noted how this shift turns him into a sort of low-rent Freddy Krueger, a comparison that begs the question: can this new supernatural iteration of The Grabber recapture the dread of the original, or will he be hampered by the "convoluted and often confusing rules" mentioned in another report? It's a delicate balance, trying to evolve a beloved villain without losing what made him so frightening in the first place.
With Ethan Hawke returning, even in this new spectral form, there's an undeniable pull. You wonder how he’ll embody this version of the character, especially given one observer felt his performance in the first film had a certain "swishy, effeminate flare" that might be absent this time around. Will the mask still hide a menace that transcends the physical?
The Black Phone 2 is set to arrive in theaters on October 17th, and I, for one, am curious to see if this sequel can build on the success of the first film, or if it might be one of those calls we wish we hadn't answered.